I wrote this in an earlier post:
Small example: I hate traveling back during peak hour. No matter how much noise I make, the transport companies aren’t going to fix things in the short term. So I make my own plans to ensure that my own commuting experience is a pleasant one.
Someone asked me to elaborate. I’ll try. But let’s temper the expectations – what I’m sharing isn’t new. Lots of people have been doing it. It is more of a change of my own thinking to help make life just a wee bit happier for me.
The Singapore Public Transport problem is really simple. It can be roughly summed up below:
Public Transport Experience = k(Resources(t) – Consumers(t)) where k is a positive coefficient and t is time.
In Singapore’s case, it is evident that at certain times of the day, the public transport experience is negative because the number of consumers stretch the resources to, and sometimes pass, its limits.
I can’t control the resources part of the equation. What I can do, is control the consumers part. I can also increase k.
So how do I do it?
To improve k.
1. I subscribe to mailing lists. I do this so that my BlackBerry will always have something interesting to read. Surfing the net when commuting is a terrible experience. Reading email which gets loaded throughout the day isn’t.
Some people read books, listen to music, play games or watch videos on their portable players. I read email from mailing lists I have selected with care.
2. I go in with the mindset I’m not going to try to get a seat no matter how tired I am. I take it as a given that the default is standing. I take it as a default that I’m going to be squeezed like a sardine. If there is a seat, I resist going to sit on it even if no one seems interested to have a sit.
I do the above to train myself to manage my expectations on the public transport experience. Once I can lower my expectations, then whatever shit happens, well, I don’t get upset thus my k-coefficient is maintained.
The problem is not the level of your experience. The problem is the gap between the level of your experience and the expectations for that experience.
I know I know…self deception.
I also started observing at the various stations I usually board the train which cars are the one that have the least among of people. I think people are predictable and thus the distribution of people being squeezed into cabins do follow a pattern.
Some people might say that for a really packed train, there is no difference between cabins. I beg to differ. However, these observations are totally unscientific and this might just be another case of a self-deceptive coping mechanism.
I control the time I take the public transport.
I realized the problem with t is this – I suspect most people do not like to go to work early or leave work late. I’ve been thinking about this and I realized it is a mindset thing. People see the office as this terrible place that must be escaped. If the work you do is something you enjoy, then I think this issue is slightly mitigated, so first rule – get a job which allows you to do work you actually love.
For going to work, I start observing at which time leaving the house allows me to minimize bus waiting time and overall transport time. Usually this means you get to the office real early or real late. I started bringing my home laptop so I could do my own stuff in the office if I got there really early. I also started pushing the boundaries of how late I could actually get to work before the higher management actually said something; once I knew the actual markers, I planned accordingly.
Fortunately, my dad recently changed his morning driving route so now on most days I get a ride to the MRT.
Anyway, I used to think once office hours were over, the office was a place that needed to be escaped. I think that’s why you see people rushing off all at the same time once the standard hours are over. So I started changing the way I view my office. It becomes a base for me to live a life. I plan non-work related stuff to do in the office. I bring a book that I can read in the office. I searched out for places around my office that I can explore or just hang out by myself.
Of course, not everyone has the, what I consider, good fortune to be working in the city. Plus a good deal of people do not have the luxury of going back later because of kids or other family commitments.
Also, there might be times you have to rush off somewhere because of other plans. Besides trying to make all my plans in the city, what I do is this – I increased my walking range.
I’ve been walking from Shenton Way to Orchard Road, River Valley, Suntec City. Just yesterday, I walked from Lau Pa Sat to the National Library to return the books then walked to Sim Lim Square to take a bus home.
I’ve also started walking home from Newton MRT to my place. The trick I learned is to plan to walk home before you hit the bus stop. The reason is that when you already planned to walk home, the experience is much better than waiting for the bus then deciding to walk home because the bus is just taking so damn bloody long to arrive.
I’ve also started researching what sort of bike to buy once I move house and the possibility of cycling to work from the new place. I also started checking out my floor and realized the handicap toilet has shower facilities which I can use when I, hopefully, start cycling to work.
The thing is, we are so used to cars, buses and MRT that we forgot that these ways of traveling was never always a given. I still can remember the stories my elders would tell me about how they would walk home from school just to save a little bit of money. We could learn from that, not so much to save money, but to find a different way to get around in an urban environment.

Priss | 20-Aug-08 at 8:07 pm | Permalink
Please don’t take this the wrong way….
You’re almost as crazy as me… ^^
Sadly, you won’t get to read any of my inner thoughts which I only share with my significant other… But yeah, know that what you blogged about is totally whacked but you’re not alone
WhiteDuskRed | 20-Aug-08 at 8:36 pm | Permalink
Walking is really a great option. In HK I have given up on the mini-buses serving my area because they are packed from 7pm-10:30pm. So I walk all the way from Mong Kok to my place… which is 30 minutes. I have even walked an 1hr+ from Tsim Sha Tsui to my place. Do I enjoy it? Definitely! I get to see people walking their dog, take in the sights and enjoy the quietness… You can never understand how people can talk so loud into their mobile phones on the mini-buses…
nocturne | 20-Aug-08 at 8:42 pm | Permalink
Siang tang nian… we walked miles to and from school every day.
With backpacks that were half our weight.
Uphill.
Both ways.
In the snow.
iantimothy | 20-Aug-08 at 10:25 pm | Permalink
@Priss hmmm … only my significant other knows the really whacked thoughts…those on this blog…have been sanitized…lol…but thanks for the showing of solidarity!
@WhiteDuskRed don’t really know these places you’re talking about in HK….
never been there. However, I still can agree with you that walking has its advantages!
motd | 21-Aug-08 at 10:57 am | Permalink
Cycling to work is an interesting idea.
But would it take longer for you to reach your destination?
Not all office have shower room as well. Maybe that is why not many people cycle to work.
The Singapore Daily » Blog Archive » Daily SG: 21 Aug 2008 | 21-Aug-08 at 12:00 pm | Permalink
[...] Daily Discourse – BothSidesOfTheJohorStraits: The Advisory Council on the Impact of New Media on Society; a necessary mouthful? – Ian On The Red Dot: How I Try To Make My Public Transport Experience More Enjoyable [...]
brian | 21-Aug-08 at 12:09 pm | Permalink
haha, i think they’re extremely useful lifehacks!
iantimothy | 21-Aug-08 at 12:14 pm | Permalink
hey hey…how to download your songs without myspace account?
iantimothy | 21-Aug-08 at 12:16 pm | Permalink
hey @motd..i’ve been thinking about that…I think the gyms in the city can start a secondary business to support cyclists…especially if we start getting bicycle lanes!
vinyarb | 21-Aug-08 at 1:28 pm | Permalink
I think what you’ve done is right. I’ve also been taking the last or first carriages in the train to work, and it IS slightly less crowded.
I too am not expecting a sit each time I board, and am leaving work later, just so the crowd is not so maddening.
As to walking… I have not gotten to your level yet.
haha.
Gary | 21-Aug-08 at 1:53 pm | Permalink
I hv been jogging back from work (abt 9 km) abr twice a week since 5 yrs ago. Believe me, it is very invigorating n gives me the peaceful 1 hr when I am on my own. It is the time when i collect my thoughs/ponder over anything n get to observe a lot of things, stuff you normally will not even bother in a crowded train/bus. Try it n you will never look back.
iantimothy | 21-Aug-08 at 2:11 pm | Permalink
Whoa…@Gary..nice…but how about the bags?
fooi | 21-Aug-08 at 2:58 pm | Permalink
Positive thinking… I like it. You are such and few ppl that could sacrifice own self to solve the problem. Nice~~
brian | 21-Aug-08 at 3:24 pm | Permalink
@iantimothy: i think you need to be a member.. but i created this
http://www.box.net/shared/df6skqjrqm
iantimothy | 21-Aug-08 at 5:57 pm | Permalink
Wee…….@brian ..thanks!! can I share the link?
brian | 27-Aug-08 at 10:56 am | Permalink
yes yes -) please share away
Ivan Chew | 07-Sep-08 at 10:34 pm | Permalink
Wah, so complicated your forumla!
My philosophy is simple: I focus on getting home safely and on time, rather than worry about getting seats etc. Getting on the bus/ train is good enough. To ensure productive use of traveling/ waiting time, I make sure I carry a book or magazine. If it’s not possible to read, I do some reflection and write on my PDA. Or I listen to music and space out.
iantimothy | 07-Sep-08 at 11:38 pm | Permalink
Hey @Ivan – it’s my bad habit…i tend to complicate things.